Thursday, 16 August 2018

My verdict of the verdict, and judging the judgment

Okay, so, here’s the detailed analysis I was promising. For those of you who were impatient for this to happen, I can only say we were waiting on the written decision. 

As you can see from this screenshot, which I took at around 10:30AM on August 15, the decision itself hasn’t been uploaded to the publicly accessible database. So 15 days after the decision was read in court, it still wasn’t up. Alison finally ordered a transcript be produced at HBB’s expense.

Why wait for the transcript? Because going by memory and notes regarding a complicated oral decision isn’t the best way to go. No one but the court itself is allowed to video or audio record anything that goes on inside the courtroom. They create transcripts based on their recording, and do not make the recordings themselves available. 

I balked at going from memory. I don’t want to get things wrong. There were a few things I have commented on publicly, but they’re things I was VERY certain of, things that stuck out in particular, and there’s just no way a lengthy oral decision can be memorized (unless you’re some kind of savant, which I’m not). 

So. At long last, here we go.

I’m going to go point by point, reading the judge’s reasons individually, and then commenting on them immediately thereafter. The first bit is just a general description of the basic details of the case—who’s suing whom and why. No need to get into that.

So. Let’s get right into the reasons. (Quotes from the decision are in bold, my commentary follows in normal font.)

Judge notes that:

In brief, the defendant Calgary Comic alleges the plaintiff breached the defendant’s policies and were removed as an exhibitor. The contract is comprised of an application form being submitted with appropriate fee and acknowledgement that, among other things, the plaintiff would adhere to Calgary Comic’s policies. 

The plaintiff’s expenses in preparing for, travelling to, and setting up at the expo may be recoverable damages in whole or in part in the breach of contract action if a breach is established. The removal of the plaintiff’s booth partway through the exposition was at the defendant’s discretion subject to contractual obligations. The plaintiff had full knowledge of what she was signing and what she was signing up for. The defendant, Calgary Comic, is a private commercial operation, and perspective applicants are free to apply or not, as they wish. 

The plaintiff asserts the notion of unequal bargaining power ought to be a consideration. The unequal bargaining power submission is not applicable in these circumstances. She applied to be an exhibitor with eyes wide open, fully knowledgeable with respect to the terms and conditions under which the defendant operated and to which she was subject. 

Yet the documents attached to the contract stipulate that all complaints will be investigated and describes its investigative process (which includes getting both sides of the story); and that a step by step process of remedy will be used to remedy sustained complaints—namely that the first step will be to ask the offending party to cease the offending conduct or remove the offending materials. 

Further, the policy documents describe “unwarranted accusations” as a form of harassment.

What this means is that Alison had an obligation to abide by the terms and conditions spelled out not only in the application form, but in the policy documents attached to the application. 

So basically, what Alison was “signing up for” was spelled out in those documents, including the policies and processes Calgary Expo had outlined regarding their complaints and investigation procedures, as well as their procedures for remedy.

The only clause in the contract relieving Calgary Expo from its own duty to abide by the terms it had laid out reads as:

“The CCEE shall have the full power in the interpretation and enforcement of all contract regulations contained herein, and the power to make such amendments thereto, and such further rules and regulations as shall be considered necessary and proper.”

Not only is this clause arguably in violation of the Alberta Consumer Protection Act and something that should never stand up in court (and usually does not), in that it grants Calgary Expo the authority to ignore its own contractual obligations as stated by it in its own documents, it does indeed raise the issue of unequal bargaining power.

If Party 1 to a contract is signing a contract filled with terms and conditions written entirely by Party 2, while a single clause in that contract indicates that Party 2 is effectively signing a blank piece of paper upon which it can choose to write anything it wishes, then the contract is not actually a contract.

Many contracts used as boilerplate by corporations like the Expo include such clauses, despite their dubious ability to succeed in court, because rubes and noobs who read that clause will believe they have no legal recourse and won’t file a lawsuit or a complaint with consumer protection agencies. 

What the judge seems to have done is uphold a clause that is in direct violation of consumer interests and consumer protection laws in Alberta, because that’s the only way I can see him claiming that Alison had an obligation to live up to the terms and conditions in the policy documents and the Expo did not. 

There was no misrepresentation by the defendant of any sort, and no evidence of bad faith. In fact, evidence shows the plaintiff’s application and the plaintiff were dealt with fairly and in a courteous manner, at least up to the point of expulsion.

Yeah, things were going great, until they weren’t. Calgary Expo treated Alison fairly, right up until they decided not to. My tenant paid the rent on time every month, until she stopped. My spouse was faithful to me, right up until he cheated. I paid my credit card balance, until that period of 6 months when I didn’t.

This assertion is irrelevant and nonsensical. It has zero bearing on whether a contract was violated. That guy had no cause to complain about my behavior, at least until the point where I punched him in the face for no reason. Good grief.

The defendant, Calgary Comic, received complaints about the plaintiff’s participation at a panel discussion and also about a banner at her booth. The defendant investigated. The investigation was not thorough in that the plaintiff had little, if any, opportunity to provide her version of events.

First thing, Alison didn’t have little if any opportunity to give her version of events. She had NO opportunity to do so. She even informed Calgary Expo’s chief of operations, Shayne Henkelman, that she had an exculpatory recording of the panel discussion, and he refused to even consider listening to it. 

I suppose, “little, if any,” might be applicable to, “but I’m innocent, and can prove it.” But at the same time, Henkelman testified that the decision was made before he even spoke to Alison that morning, with no opportunity for her to give her version.

Secondly, how is this “not thorough” investigation sufficient to come to a decision to evict, if the contract Alison signed indicated that all complaints would be investigated by getting both sides of the story, and remedied in a gradual manner as outlined earlier?

The defendant said it received complaints from guests, news organizations, and from TheMarySue. It went online to learn more about the prominent Gamergate banner at the plaintiff’s booth. 

To my knowledge, Expo received no complaints from the Mary Sue (or even employees or agents of the Mary Sue), nor did Shayne Henkelman testify that they did. 

Also, complaints were received from the personal accounts of media personalities, but not from official news media accounts, as far as I know. It’s kind of like the difference between saying “Tucker Carlson tweeted X,” and “Fox News tweeted X.” 

This is a really strange mistake for the judge to make, since HAD the Mary Sue officially complained about us to Calgary Expo, this would have helped to implicate them in any inducing breach of contract claim, particularly if the complaint had no merit.

The online information about Gamergate was unsavory, to say the least, and, in the view of the FBI, Gamergate is a vehicle used to disseminate hate messages among others. 

Like the coverage of Alison and HBB following our expulsion? Unsavory like that?

Anyway, his assertion about the FBI is directly contradicted by the only evidence regarding them that was presented at trial. This position attributed to the FBI could not have even been found by improper, out of court research. The FBI investigated Gamergate over accusations that it was a hate movement, and it found no actionable leads. Law enforcement identified four individuals who’d sent potentially illegal messages, one of them a minor, and chose not to prosecute any of them. One was clearly a joke (at least to anyone who’s ever spent any time online), claiming to have “over 9000 bombs” and another prescribing tea, hugs a gentle back massage and face-melting high ordinance explosives for feminists. 

With respect to the breach of policy application, in order to succeed, the plaintiff must show on a balance that the defendant Calgary Comic’s reliance on its policies was sufficiently unfounded to constitute a breach of its contractual obligations. 

Regardless of the quality of the investigation and regardless of the fact that the defendant’s reasons for its decision may well have been debatable, it had the contractual right to remove the plaintiff’s booth subject, of course, to its contractual obligations to the plaintiff. 

Wait, aren’t those obligations spelled out in the exhibitor agreement and other policy documents attached to the contract? Again, we’re back to this idea that vendors have an obligation to abide by the terms and conditions laid out by the Expo, while the Expo has no such obligation. 

And again, we’re back to that sticky “we reserve the right to do whatever we want for any reason or no reason whatsoever” clause that, if legal, would certainly make unequal bargaining power a consideration. 

The plaintiff denied being disruptive at the panel discussion and provided a transcript and audio recording to support her assertion. Both the tape and transcript are somewhat supportive of the plaintiff’s position. However, the quality of the recording makes it difficult to discern what is said and by whom. I recognize the difficulty in marshalling this kind of evidence. However, I don’t know if the portions provided are the complete exchange in issue, much less whether they are the portions complained of. 

First off, the judge spent much of the trial reminding counsel and witnesses to speak up because he's hard of hearing. I would suggest that it being “difficult to discern what is said and by whom” might be owing to a disability on the part of the judge rather than on the quality of the recording. 

In addition, the judge had ruled against listening to the entire recording at trial. When asked why she wanted to play the entire thing, Alison responded that she wanted her participation to be viewed in the context of the entire discussion. Defence didn’t want to listen to the whole thing, and neither did the judge, and BOTH indicated they would take her word for it that the excerpts were satisfactory in that regard. For the judge to now complain about the incompleteness of evidence he himself ruled against hearing in full is… well. Moving on.

While debatable, I cannot conclude on balance that there is sufficient credible evidence to conclude Calgary Comic’s assessment of the information it received and gathered and its application of that information to its policies was a sufficiently inadequate misinterpretation or a misapplication so as to constitute an improper application of its policies and thus a breach of its contractual obligations with the plaintiff. Thus, there is insufficient evidence to support the breach of contract claim against Calgary Comic, and accordingly, that claim is dismissed.

Policies which state clearly that an investigation involves getting both sides of the story, that unwarranted accusations are a form of harassment, and which also state that remedy begins with asking the offending party to cease the offending conduct—that is, putting people on notice. The Expo acted precipitously and summarily on information it received and gathered from everyone BUT the plaintiff, and bypassed all of the steps it outlined for remedy to level the most extreme punishment available to it—not just expulsion, but a blanket ban on attendance of future conventions.

Further, Henkelman testified on the stand that even had he known that all of the allegations in the various complaints against Alison made to Calgary Expo were false, he’d have ejected her anyway. 

What we are left with is Alison’s alleged “association” with a hashtag called Gamergate, standing as the sole reason for her being evicted. 

However, there was NOTHING in the contract or the surrounding policies or exhibitor agreement putting her on notice that presenting a Gamergate logo on a banner promoting anti-censorship and pro-ethics values would be in violation of ANY of the Expo’s policies. There was nothing in the contract or policies prohibiting expressing affiliation with ANY movement, hashtag, political opinion, cause or philosophy.

Inducing breach of contract:

Judge notes:

With respect to the inducing breach of contract claim regarding TheMarySue, the defendant, Calgary Comic’s representative testified he had no contact with TheMarySue apart from receiving the complaint about the events in question prior to the decision to expel the plaintiff from the exposition. There is suspicion by the plaintiff that TheMarySue and Calgary Comic may have collaborated or colluded and that TheMarySue may have slagged the plaintiff, thereby inducing Calgary Comic to act as it did, but there is insufficient credible supporting evidence in that regard, and thus the inducing breach of contract claim against TheMarySue is dismissed. 

This is not accurate. Again, Calgary Expo received no complaints from the Mary Sue, or from any agent of the Mary Sue. He may be referring to the complaint from Brittany LeBlanc, but neither Alison nor Shayne ever said there were complaints from the Mary Sue. 

As for the suspicion of collusion, yes, this was our suggestion in our initial filing. However, the scenario we presented at trial and during final submissions, after more digging and the evidence exchange, was very different. The scenario we presented was that Sam Maggs sent a photo of our booth to her friend and collaborator in Toronto, Soha Kareem, who tweeted it out. This single tweet was what led to ALL of the complaints on social media from guests and news media personalities that Henkelman cited as the ultimate reason he kicked us out (that is, the complaints led him to take other actions which led to that decision). 

In addition, our contention was that Sam Maggs spoke privately to Brittany LeBlanc and convinced her to complain to Calgary Expo about Alison’s participation at the panel (which was another reason Henkelman cited in his testimony as contributing to his decision to kick us out). 

So our contention at trial was that Sam Maggs, editor for the Mary Sue, intentionally set out to generate a social media controversy with us as the target, in order to create news for her website to then report on. 

And wouldn’t you know it? The Mary Sue scooped the story.

We certainly had more evidence supporting our conjecture that Sam Maggs, in her position as editor of the Mary Sue, orchestrated a social media controversy through a known associate, a social media controversy that was the ultimate cause of our expulsion (according to Henkelman). Yet the judge didn’t touch on this at all, not even to say it was far fetched, or a conspiracy theory, or even that our evidence of it was insufficient. 

He just ignored it.

Injurious falsehood, Calgary Expo:

Judge notes:

There is insufficient credible evidence that the defendant Calgary Comic published anything, much less any false statements disparaging the plaintiff’s goods or property or business. Having her booth removed from the exposition for breach of the defendant’s policies, without more, does not constitute a false statement. Publication of the fact of removal of the booth for breach of policy, without more, is also not a false statement. 

Really? I mean, I’ll grant that it is not necessarily a false statement. That is, if the breach of policy had occurred, or if a fair investigation adhering to Calgary Expo’s contractual obligations had occurred, even if the finding was wrong. A false statement doesn’t require someone to know the statement is false. Malice, in the context of false statements, can include not taking the proper care to check. 

The Expo had contractual obligations to take proper care to check, as it itself laid out in its policy documents and attached to the contract. It did not do so prior to its decision that we had violated policy, nor before its publication of that information. Henkelman’s testimony describes a rush to judgment and summary execution completely devoid of taking proper care to check. 

In fact, in his final submissions, he described this as the first and only case in which he himself ever kicked anyone out of one of the events run by Calgary Expo. Are we to believe that no one else has ever been ejected from a fan expo in western Canada? Or are we to believe Mr. Henkelman’s testimony, that he, as Expo’s chief of operations took it upon himself to unilaterally bypass all of the Expo’s dedicated personnel and procedures, and its obligations as spelled out in the policy documents to make what amounted to an executive order in violation of its contractual obligations? 

Publication by others of the expulsion and the purported reasons for the expulsion are not actionable against the defendant Calgary Comic. The defendant Calgary Comic did not publish the fact of the expulsion or the reasons for it. Tweets by others posted on the Calgary Comic website about the expulsion were quickly removed by it. Alternatively, if the tweets by others could be characterized as publication by Calgary Comic, there is insufficient credible evidence that the tweets contained false statements about the plaintiff’s property, goods, or business. 

No no no. First, tweets were not published on Calgary Expo’s website. They were published on Twitter. Calgary Expo cannot remove tweets made by “others” from Twitter. It can only remove its own tweets. Further, it cannot make tweets made by “others” invisible to anyone but itself. 

And secondly, in direct response to a tweeted query as to why we were kicked out, Calgary Expo’s official Twitter account tweeted the Mary Sue’s article. A tweet constitutes publication of everything contained therein, including links.

And finally, Henkelman testified ON THE STAND that he ordered the tweet deleted when he learned of its existence. His stated reason, under oath, for doing so was that the tweet was ACTIONABLE. In other words, Calgary Expo published actionable statements it knew might be false, and Henkelman ordered them deleted BECAUSE they were actionable.

His actions in deleting the tweet, and his stated reasons for doing so, were an admission that the tweet itself WAS INDEED actionable under the law. This tweet was not made by “others”, but by Calgary Expo’s official social media account, manned by employees and agents of Calgary Expo and working under Calgary Expo’s authorization. 

If I am wrong that the defendant did not publish statements about the plaintiff’s goods, property, or business, there is insufficient credible evidence that any such purported statements were false. 

This is… bizarre, since the tweet contained a link to the Mary Sue article, in direct answer to a query as to why we were kicked out. The article describes HBB as a business run by someone who lies on her business contracts in order to clandestinely gain opportunities to cause disruption and harass people. Alison did not lie on her contract. We did NOT sneak into the convention. And while there, we harassed no one.

Of course, there is credible evidence. It’s there in the booth application. In our badges and booth decal identifying who we were. And the judge is the person who ruled we wouldn’t hear the entirety of the panel discussion that would have provided credible evidence that Alison had harassed no one. 

In the further alternative, if I am wrong about the publication and falsity of content, there 1 is no credible evidence that the defendant Calgary Comic was motivated by malice. The 2 evidence showed the defendant received complaints about the plaintiff’s conduct and about 3 a banner at her booth and after some investigation chose to have her booth closed and 4 removed from the exposition. 

He really seems to be wanting to cover all his bases. However.

Malice: a conscious, intentional wrongdoing of a civil wrong like libel, with the intention of doing harm to the victim. This intention includes ill-will, hatred, or total disregard for the other's well-being.

Calgary Expo’s policies, attached to their contract, clearly state that unwarranted accusations are considered a form of harassment, and that its investigation of complaints will take into account both sides of the story. 

Calgary Expo’s contravention of its own stated policies and procedures in this case certainly displayed no regard for the wellbeing of Alison when it summarily ejected her despite her telling them she had exonerating evidence. 

When Calgary Expo promoted the Mary Sue article in response to questions as to the reason it had evicted Alison, it also did so with total disregard for her wellbeing. Calgary Expo's social media team did not take time to verify whether the allegations in the article were true or false, which it could have easily done at least in regard to the "misrepresentation" claim, prior to tweeting the article.

And further, when Calgary Expo deleted the tweet, it did not do so to ameliorate any unjust damage done to Alison, but merely to protect itself from what it knew were legally actionable statements on its part. 

To this day, Calgary Expo has not so much as corrected the public allegation that Alison lied on her contract with them, despite having submitted evidence to that effect to the court. Which certainly displays continued disregard for her wellbeing.

There is no evidence of animus towards the plaintiff or bad faith in investigating the complaints, notwithstanding Calgary Comic did not obtain the plaintiff’s input prior to its decision to expel. 

Except that it did not follow the investigatory protocols laid out in its own policies and agreements. It refused to listen to evidence Alison claimed was exculpatory. That's the definition of bad faith. 

That Mr. Henkelman and the Expo were nice to us right up until the moment that they weren’t is immaterial. 

Expo did not follow its prescribed step by step procedure for remedy even when someone is found to be engaging in offending conduct. It skipped over all of its normal procedures, and jumped directly from accusation to summary execution. 

As to animus, Alison was informed that if her booth was not dismantled and all of us out within half an hour, Mr. Henkelman would call police and have us all arrested. He refused to provide us with tools when asked, so we could disassemble the booth without damaging it. 

He testified that following our eviction he sent “spies” to infiltrate our social gatherings and report back to him. He put Stampede security on notice that we were a clear and present danger, such that Stampede security called police on our peaceful and completely innocent picnic at Reader Rock Garden.

No animus? I call bullshit.

Lastly, if I am wrong about publication, falsity, and malice, the plaintiff has not led sufficient credible evidence to establish special damages. Damages are not presumed, and general damages are not recoverable. The plaintiff incurred expenses to attend the exposition, but those expenses were not a result of this alleged actionable tort. 

Good grief. Because being smeared in both mainstream and industry media can’t be reasonably expected to hurt your bottom line in your chosen industry? 

Damages are not presumed, but a reasonable expectation of damages does not mean that the plaintiff must present an itemized list down to the penny of every loss suffered. It does not require a plaintiff to be clairvoyant and prove that, if not for the defendant’s actions, they’d have sold exactly 2113 units of merchandise. 

The plaintiff’s husband testified that she had sold about 30 comics in her entire career.

Therefore, there were no damages? Plaintiff’s husband also testified that he had no real idea how many comics she’d sold. A subsequent witness testified that this estimate was way off. 

Regardless, a subsequent witness who was manning the booth testified that 7 copies of Alison’s comic were sold in the first four hours of the convention alone. Projecting from this, Alison could have expected to sell a total of 50 to 60 comics over the full Expo, had she been allowed to stay. That’s double the lifetime estimate given, under pressure, from her husband, and it applies just to one event. 

The plaintiff testified she experienced difficulty convincing store owners to carry her product after this event. There was insufficient evidence of the magnitude of her difficulties, much less a dollar amount to specify the amount of alleged special damages loss. Thus, the injurious falsehood claim is dismissed against Calgary Comic.

This is a mischaracterization. Alison testified that a store owner in Saskatoon had not only stocked her books, but had placed them on prominent display to promote a local artist. After the incident and the media fallout, that shop owner took down the display and cut her orders by 75%.

There is no down to the penny specificity requirement under injurious falsehood as to what determining there were special damages, nor a minimum amount necessary. If there is a reasonable expectation that Alison had lost out on the sale of just one book due to this fiasco, that would be enough to constitute special damages. The amount of the special damages only becomes relevant when deciding what, if anything, is owing to the plaintiff. 

Injurious falsehood, The Mary Sue:

Judge notes:

TheMarySue did not participate in the whole trial. It did not lead evidence nor cross- examine nor make submissions. It published an article after the expulsion. Some of the content may be false, and it may have been written maliciously. Assuming, without deciding, that there was publication, maliciousness and falsehood, I would dismiss the claim on the basis there was no credible evidence that the plaintiff suffered special damages attributable to TheMarySue publication. Thus, the injurious falsehood claim is dismissed against TheMarySue. 

And again, there is no requirement for specificity regarding an exact dollar amount to prove special damages, nor a lower bound as to what is considered a pecuniary loss. A reasonable expectation of loss is sufficient to prove injurious falsehood.

Anyway, there’s so much that’s haywire with this decision, it’s not even funny. I think I counted a minimum of 16 grounds on which to appeal. And that’s not even considering some of the errors of factfinding that occurred.

The judge disregarded Henkelman’s own testimony that the Calgary Expo’s tweet was actionable. 

His finding of no animus is completely belied by the manner in which we were kicked out—Henkelman refusing to hear exculpatory evidence and even threatening to have us arrested if we weren’t gone by the time the doors opened to the public. Henkelman advising Stampede security that we were a threat to safety at the convention, and sending staff members to spy on our meet-ups. No evidence of animus there. 

And perhaps the most ironic thing of all was all of that animus appears to have been based on the egregiously biased, misleading and demonizing media coverage of Gamergate that falsely painted a hashtag and a consumer revolt as something sinister and dangerous. And the result of his actions? Egregiously biased, misleading and demonizing media coverage of Honey Badger Brigade and the events of April 2015.


  1. Is there any possibility of an appeal?

  2. Welcome to Court. Now you know why Men get shafted so often in Family Court.

    Of course I agree with most of your points - and substance of your arguments - but as you have discovered "going to court" is not for the faint-hearted or non-deep pocketed.

    You have just started (even though it feels like Round 8) now that you have a judgement your Appeal is the next step to get some true perspective on this case with 3 other Judges.

    Building up some public support or outrage at this idiots decision is probably not a a bad idea at this point - although you should not use words like "idiot".

    Your video is a good start in the counter-attack. Have you a isolated a dedicated webpage where we can find all documents & evidence to support case & arguement made to date?

    I suggest you look at Dr Ferrel Christenson's dedicated website that he put up after the settlement of his defamation case in June 2009 that IMHO was only necessary as the PostMedia Sale was looming and this was an attempt to reduce the most obvious liabilities (the defamation began with series of malignant articles starting on March 30, 2001)

  3. Holy cow. You should've been a lawyer. This analysis of your shows that our legal system is utterly corrupt. It consists of endless hairsplitting, not any kind of search for the truth.

  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  5. welcome to artificial reality Karen...

    I'll tell you what a grade school prinipal told me before my divorce: "Dont expect justice".

    The system is biased for itself.

    Better to do damage in the conceptual war zone...

    I find you can plant concepts in comments sections on news sites and have the concepts go viral if they are original and truth.
    It takes letting go of being important and focusing on targets and goals...

  6. “The CCEE shall have the full power in the interpretation and enforcement of all contract regulations contained herein, and the power to make such amendments thereto, and such further rules and regulations as shall be considered necessary and proper.”
    This is a "get out of our obligations free" card for any monopoly that wishes to use it. I hope it's inclusion is mentioned prominently in the appeal.
    I am assuming Calgary Comic, or whoever she made the contract with, is the sole entity from which interested parties could be assigned a booth for that particular event. If so, that makes them a monopoly.
    The judge's decision, in this regard, was neither just nor reasonable.

  7. Thanks for sharing this article about Posting, Followed by you I did started Guest Posting for my blog.

    slot online
    slot games
    free slots

  8. I enjoyed over read your blog post.
    Your blog have nice information, I got good ideas from this amazing blog.
    I am always searching like this type blog post. I hope I will see again…

    casino games
    คา สิ โน ออนไลน์ ฟรี

  9. Công ty dịch thuật Sài Gòn là nhà cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật tại TP Hồ Chí Minh: biên dịch (dịch chuyên ngành, dịch công chứng Sài Gòn, phiên dịch chuyên nghiệp tại Lầu 6, tòa nhà becamex, 47 Điện Biên Phủ, Đakao, Quận 1, TP Hồ Chí Minh. Công ty dịch thuật Sài Gòn vinh dự và tự hào được đánh giá là địa chỉ công ty dịch thuật tiếng Hàn cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật hơn 50 ngôn ngữ khác nhau như tiếng Anh, tiếng Nhật, tiếng Trung, tiếng Pháp, tiếng Đức, tiếng Nga, tiếng Tây Ban Nha, Bồ Đào Nha, Thái Lan, Lào, Campuchia, Thụy Điển, Thổ Nhĩ Kỳ…Với phong cách làm việc nghiêm túc, chuyên nghiệp nhằm mang đến cho Quý khách hàng tại thành phố Hồ Chí Minh trải nghiệm tốt nhất trên thị trường

  10. I want to share a testimony on how Le_Meridian funding service helped me with loan of 2,000,000.00 USD to finance my marijuana farm project , I'm very grateful and i promised to share this legit funding company to anyone looking for way to expand his or her business project.the company is UK/USA funding company. Anyone seeking for finance support should contact them on Or Mr Benjamin is also on whatsapp 1-989-394-3740 to make things easy for any applicant. 

  11. Thanks For Sharing Blog

  12. Thanks for this information

  13. thanks for share this blog

  14. thanks for share this blog

  15. thanks for share this blog

  16. Course Perfect we serve you the best study abroad guidance.


  17. The article provides good information and here i want to share some information about oracle training and oracle apex training

  18. I am very happy to read the above information. It is really helpful for me, I learned many new things from your website. Big thanks to you all for everything and I am really very happy.
    Best Handloom Saree Shops
    Matka Silk Sarees
    Pure Resham Silk Sarees
    Gachi Tussar Sarees
    Khadi Cotton Saree


  19. Hi,

    Thank you so much for sharing such a nice artical about Nepal trekking of Annapurna Poon Hill. I am also happy to give some more information about the Nepal trek.
    Trekking company in Nepal has other package such as Everest Base Camp Trek , Manaslu Circuit trek , Island Peak Climbing , Mardi Himal Trek , Annapurna Circuit trek
    Thank you!


  20. Wow. That is so elegant and logical and clearly explained. Brilliantly goes through what could be a complex process and makes it obvious.I want to refer about the best data science training


  21. Great post. This post will be very useful to me. Thanks, Dear Author for this rocking post.
    handloom saree shop in kolkata
    top saree shops in kolkata
    Handloom sarees
    bengali saree

  22. Amazing!!! It was very Amazing post. After Read your post I am too amazed. I’ll follow your every Post. I also write a blog for those students who wants to take admission in SRM University which is located in India. It’s famous for all professional Courses. I am sharing a link if anybody wants to do any professional course. They can follow the link.

  23. Thank you for sharing such wonderful information related to this topic. Your writing style is good and the way you present facts is impressive. I have also done an article on the same topic. Please visit our website link
    BITS Pilani IMPORTANT DATES to read that article. There are some more facts about BITS Pilani.and info about the topic. Also please tell us how was it.

  24. The Content is very good and Niche Oriented. Thanks for sharing this Blog
    Way4Fly is offering Delta Airlines Flights Reservations at the cheap cost for the reservations online

  25. Thank You very much for your informational blog about this. Dear Author for this rocking post.
    Adderall Bad
    Adderall Affect

  26. Thank You very much for your informational blog about this. Quite an interesting post by author. Detailed, and much informative. Best UI UX Design Agency In Mumbai, India Text

  27. You write amazingly this blog, thanks for sharing this
    Fares Match is now offering up to 30% Flat Discount on the
    British Airways Reservations

  28. Your content is very attractive and useful in which the authenticity looks like the services of our website are also authentic and the content is also useful.

  29. Thanks for sharing such an Amazing information, I Couldn't leave without reading your blog. I have read another good blog, I think you have read it too. click here AVG klantendienst

  30. JIO provides free Caller Tune facility to its customers. But sometimes it happens that some people do not want to keep Caller Tune or they want to change it. If you are among those who want to know How to Remove Jio Caller Tune or Setup,then follow the step by step method given below. Complete information of Jio phone me jio tune kaise hataye in Hindi

  31. Friends, sometimes it happens to all of us that someone speaks something in short form in front of us and we do not even understand its meaning. One such word is ‘LMV-NT’ So what is LMV Driving License? lmv nt full form? and How to Apply for it we will learn everything in detail.

  32. That’s a nice article, thank you for a great article. It helped me a lot. Keep it up Must Visit Lexmark Printer nummer belgie

  33. I think this the best blog with the most important information filled in this website
    I Got the more and more ideas from this blog Thank You for letting us to know.
    pythonTraining in chennai

    python Course in chennai

  34. Looking for a South Ex escort who loves casual encounters
    We have all types of babes South Ex Escorts service like russian, south indian, punjabi, marathi, gujarai etc. who present a high class satisfaction feeling when you make a relationship with her.All the South Ex Call Girls are professionally trained and relate to high society who charge very highly individually but after contacting us
    Call Girls in South Ex
    South Ex Escorts

  35. I really found this to much informative. It is what i was searching for. I would like to suggest you that please keep sharing such type of info
    viagra tablet

  36. Hey, I'm Shweta who is looking for a pleasure time to spend with new guys.
    They know how to book call girls; they know how to enjoy with these call girls and at last, they know how to maintain privacy as well.
    Mumbai Escorts
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Mumbai Call Girls

  37. Hello Guys, My name is Ankita but people call me Miss Delhi. I am an Independent Girl, I love music and love to spend some time with hot boys. Mumbai Escorts is the best Escorts Girls service in Mumbai free and paid sex incall and outcall independent agency.

  38. Call Girls in Paharganj: - We are the unparalleled rumored accompanies administration in Paharganj from most recent couple of years. We have the Call girls in Paharganj from any remaining areas. Our Call young ladies in Paharganj are sought after for the voyagers, outsiders and many businessmen's. You can get easygoing gatherings with hot young ladies whenever they are likewise the craving to meet you. In the event that you are feeling desolate and searching for a delightful partner who can give all your necessities, at that 000int you are continuing immediately. We can orchestrate a calm sentimental date for you with our Paharganj Escorts the help is open all day, every day for you. We have a huge assortment of young ladies to settle on your longing and decisions complete. Our escorts organization currently turns into a top decision for everybody and this on account of our quality help to customers. Escorts Service in Paharganj is consistently accessible at your support of offer you the best Escorts joy in Paharganj.

  39. This is the best escort services in Connaught Place may be gainful for you on the off chance that you are looking for a mindful female partner. We give prominent call girls in Connaught place for your happiness and ravishment. In the event that you're remaining in any lavish lodging close to Connaught Place, selecting an escort young lady may upgrade your delight. We have an incredible assortment which includes a scope of alternatives so you can pick what sort of young lady makes your day. These Escort Service in Connaught place have assumed control over the holy messengers and appear to be an impression of prostitutes. There is a ton organized your delight, for example, extravagance bars and clubs where you can meet with complex females of the town. Indeed, you would happy to realize that a large number of the esteemed women of metropolitan zones of Delhi are our regarded bunch individuals. You can get one of them by calling @ 9654120218.

  40. We are related with qualified, taught proficient and elegant escort young ladies so you can invest a decent energy with these Call Girls in Mahipalpur. Our youngsters can offer their organizations at five-star lodgings, four-star motels or three-star hotels too yet in case you moreover need organization at your home they can even come there as well, they can come and visit you seven evenings each week holding up the early hours of the sunrise generally advantageous and real administrations. So Guys view our best choice of world Escort Service in Mahipalpur benefits, and connect with our telephone chief and request the best young lady chose by you from our image display. We are even accessible in a wide zone of Delhi-NCR for our administrations.

  41. Delhi Call Girls Agency, we are one among the various escort organization providing food young ladies for sexual administrations in Delhi and NCR. Our administrations are expanded all over Delhi and edges. We keep up unmistakable class of young ladies at all the majority of noticeable districts of the Delhi to guarantee our customers immediate and wanted administrations. Our Call Girls in Delhi are best class of young ladies giving extreme joy and furthermore moving message to not to surrender except if you achieve your point. Our Escort Service in Delhi attempt to change viewpoint towards life however yes they show the procedures to appreciate life and grin against the odd of life. Likewise become familiar with the procedures to make meeting more acceptable and interesting with escort young ladies.

  42. I am the most gorgeous woman in Green park escorts. you can call Green park escorts and fix a time to meet me. I will make you have the best orgasms of your life and you would be really grateful that you called me. I know many different ways to please you, so give me a chance and come spend a hot night with me. You will get great service with lots of added benefits for me. Want to get a good sexual massage? Call me right now! We can spend hours making love to each other. So, don’t hesitate and book private time with me now. Kalkaji escorts

  43. The girls who are housewives but also serving as the Housewife Call Girls to the clients and this time the maturity goes on the highest scale for you with the booking of these call girls. Due to the top maturity sense and knowledge of sex moves these girls are most demanded in the list.
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Church Gate Escorts

  44. Are you guys exploring modern, impressive Delhi Escort Service in Delhi? We questioned this because we are suitable for conducting premium class and pretty Delhi Call Girls for your satisfaction. If you've got been lonely for an extended time, so some time has begun. We are here to supply the foremost essential services in Delhi to you. Yes, we are talking escort services in Delhi, which has imperialism of the cutest girls within the city. We penetrate the intensity of your heart to watch your wants, and this is often what keeps us better to the remainder of others. it's difficult to be alone during this exotic city of the state .
    Call Girls in Delhi could be a far better choice for a few space for spending class time and enjoying romantic dates. the foremost satisfying part is that these expert love-makers are accessible at rock bottom rates. If you're looking for entertainment here, so what might be better than selecting an escort girl in Delhi?

  45. Welcome to the destination of life describing it's never complete without a partner. every one should have some needfulness of a partner in their life. a number of the lads are lucky they need more friends and that they are proud of their needfulness. But there are many that have the aim to still found their final destination. Welcome to the planet of the incredible lifetime of Call Girls in Mahipalpur. You’ll have your true companion for any event you've got within the world. Our Mahipalpur Escorts provides an entrancing choice for a high-quality time during a city of sovereign people.
    Escort Service in Mahipalpur were making real-time opportunities to supply a magical companionship for the critical phase of the meeting. Now, brooding about the premium escorts service, enjoy the creamy Mahipalpur Escorts Service with our female escorts. you'll feel the important joy of companionship which may offer you perfect happiness and privacy. We are covering each and each aspect to gratify your needs.

  46. After browsing a true tedious work schedule on day to day , men would have the natural wants for a few kind of relaxation and happiness. it's very obvious that the women having the glamorous appearance and desirability would be ranking within the higher position compared to the standard individuals within the list. Such is that the case with the women performing at our agency and therefore the time spend under their guidance is actually fascinating enough to quench the lusty matters of men. Independent call girls in Connaught place is understood to be the foremost intriguing experts being the perfect choice for in call also as outcall mode of services.
    It would be very easy and cozy to possess these enchanting hotdog babes in your arms as they're highly cooperative in nature and behavior. There would be few loss incurred by the purchasers to possess these ladies involved in Escort Service in Connaught place as their intimate partners who have the capabilities of providing the utmost level of erotic entertainment.

  47. The girls are entertaining and sparking they skills to charge your body. They like to entertain new peoples who are affected by a stressful life. all of them wish to provide you with the pleasure of a high level. we offer you together with your choice and desirable Escorts in Paharganj for the acute sex. Our agency has many Call girls in Paharganj who are from a special community. a number of the women are a university student, busty ramp models and therefore the hot housewives who are trying to find hardcore sex.
    The girl will satisfy your sexual needs and take you the peak of utmost pleasure. all of them girls love, to be frank, or close with strangers, they not want to waste time with an uneventful life and she or he loves the thrills of the sexual comrade. Our Escorts Service in Paharganj are highly qualified and well mannered, you'll also get her for the occasions and therefore the parties.
    Click here > > paharganj escort

  48. India have one state where everything gets available as safe and instant you'd wish to have. So, Delhi have one beautiful place is understood because it Hub of India as an Escort Service in Nehru Place. Here everything have the simplest and every one quite things get offering and doing day to day night after night work and business you'll not have gotten ok times to measure the life for creating love making session in your life. So, if you're thinking to possess some good times with models, collage girls and call girls for naughty and kinky escorts then your wishes would be filled now and that we are here to form it all possible way too pleased and enjoying mood that you simply are brooding about making some good erotic act with Models, Escorts, and every one independent Professional that you simply would really like to require to Flat, Home or any beautiful place you'd wish to make some good times around the clock.
    Escort in Nehru Place | Nehru place call girls | Nehru place escorts
    Click here: - nehru place escorts

  49. A person who is getting a nasty experience in escort then we request you to require escort service with us we are given a full guarantee that you simply will get fully satisfied with Chanakyapuri Escort Service. we've a really much and high-class escort girls which have an outsized escort experience and still they're much demanded between the businessmen and other clients. once you see one among our escort girls you'll see why our escort service in Chanakyapuri may be a very premium escort service provider. We never choose that female who is looking beautiful and hot and shows attitudes to our valuable clients because the male is come for getting full fun and getting the time to finish the stress of creating escort. There such a lot escort girls who are are available Chanakyapuri and provides Call Girls in Chanakyapuri with us because we've a really much famous and therefore the strength of our centre is every client will get time to urge a full enjoy with a female.

  50. Are you feeling lonely? does one face the difficulty of stress and tension? you would like a change from your day to day life. we will now provide beautiful girls for your use. you'll go around with them or just stay out night. they're the ladies with motivation. Yes, they will motivate you to try to to your job. If you've got no lady in your life, select your choice Call Girls in Aerocity. they're capable of doing everything that you simply say. For them, the clients are like god. you'll get everything without asking. you'll make an idea to travel out with them. does one want to go to their office? they need apartments where both of you'll stay with none disturbance. you'll stick with them within the public place like parks, restaurants etc. a gorgeous place like Aerocity is popular for its amazing Escort Service in Aerocity and sexy escorts are the core reason of entertainment of the many adult people that wants to spend intimacy time with super-hot young babes.
    You'll call us @ 9773622641

  51. There is no need to meet with the mediator or middlemen to book call girls and you can do this task by yourself without facing any difficulty.
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Mira Road Escorts

  52. Delhi prostitute Agency, most promising and reliable call girls agency of Delhi offers status and hot Escort Service in Delhi for all those needing women publicly or closed doors. These are young and exuberant stunning collection of young chic between the age of 18 to 30 years selected from overseas and India. Our beauties from India are from southern, northern, eastern and western states of the India providing numerous choices to match up the desires and tastes of clients. this is often not all, we all present Russian escorts for turning your fantasies true through electrifying time in and off bed. These also are educated and high Hot Call Girls in Delhi with model like personality. Our Pride, Hot, sexy, beautiful words don't do justice to the captivating great thing about our escorts. We don't call on the carpet to explain the mesmeric great thing about our hottest collection of babes.
    You'll call us @ 9773622641

  53. Delhi is a tremendous city with tempting seductive Escort Service in Lajpat Nagar that has been catching the eye of high class gentlemen for pleasure. This tinsel town has something or the opposite for people from all walks of life. Being a discerning gentleman, you surely would have felt the necessity for physical pleasure.
    Sex plays a really important role within the lives of these men who are engrossed in their hectic lives revolving around business meetings, tours etc. So you would like the simplest Lajpat Nagar call girls in order that you'll spend your night with the foremost beautiful courtesan who is conscious of everything you've got on your mind.
    We at Delhi call girl’s agency, study and understand the requirements of our customers who cannot wait any more when it involves putting their sexual cravings, desires and fantasies to rest.
    You'll call us @ 9773622641
    Click here >> Call Girls in Lajpat Nagar

  54. There is no need to meet with the mediator or middlemen to book call girls and you can do this task by yourself without facing any difficulty.
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Mira Road Escorts

  55. If you're want service for the fun a night with our daring and pleasant girls then choose the services of Paharganj, Call Girls service in Paharganj and Noida so you’ll contact any time, Airport Hotel Delhi, Call Girls & Call Girls in Paharganj, Delhi Call Girls, VIP Call Girls, Bengali girls, Top VIP Call Girls, Housewife, Independent Punjabi Call Girls, Here you will get everything that you simply simply would adore in your Erotic partners then you're on right path. Our Paharganj escort services can provide you with the services and best pleasure that a private want. Paharganj is that the place of latest Delhi Airport wherever you'll get everything at their best whether or not it's related to the pleasance or to be relaxed from your daily routine. we'll give you some gutsy and unprecedented evenings with our choice women in Paharganj which is during a situation to be a sweet and waiting night for you.
    Click now: - Escorts Service in Paharganj

  56. Friends If you're within the category of not having any girls option and getting to search for Escorts, and Call Girls in Mahipalpur or Housewife to fill color your life then you're at the proper place because we will fill this blankness or lack of your life in seconds and may serve you the simplest instantly if you'd wish to get the service at a time day or within the night you'll contact us and obtain your dream girl.
    We have a good collection of all sort of escorts like Models, Independent Escort, College Girls, Housewives, Celebrities, Airhostess, Foreigners, and lots of more.
    We are related to eligible, educated professional and high-class escort girls in order that you'll spend an honest time with these Escort Service in Mahipalpur. Our girls offers their services at five-star hotels, four-star hotels or three-star hotels also but if you furthermore may want service at your home they will even come there too.
    Click now:- Escort Service in Mahipalpur

  57. Escort services are being quite common nowadays. Everyone knew that when one is looking forward to approaching Connaught Place escorts, they're looking forward to having some fun and pleasure. But it's not necessary that in your area also the Independent Connaught Place escorts are available.
    But now there's no need for you to urge worried about Escorts Services in Connaught Place is out there everywhere for you. you only got to approach the service provider and let him realize your requirements. There could be numerous questions that are rising in your mind considering the escort service in Connaught Place if you've got not availed it earlier. you would possibly be thinking, is it necessary to avail the same? But if you've got such questions in your mind and here, a number of the items are mentioned which will assist you to know whether you're able to avail of the Call Girls in Connaught place or not. At the very first, it's a requirement for a person to urge physically and mentally satisfied.
    click here:- Call Girls in Connaught place

  58. Escort Service in Aerocity for full fun and delight time during a few days. it's been seen that during a few days clients coming from other cities and countries are beguiled by observing these sites today I’m attempting to totally confound me. I even have shared some significant data about the Aerocity Escorts Service. I will be able to attempt to arrange you on how individuals aren't mistaken for the Escort Service in Delhi site who got to appreciate genuine they need to pick the right guide agency in light of the very fact that the foremost stressing thing has emerged here.
    They should know this significant thing that genuine affection is being looked through today actually since you excessively are ready to escort for physical fulfillment with the young female friends and spouses throughout your life. Sweetheart, it's an ideal opportunity to fulfill your longings by recruiting the new and hottest Aerocity accompanies for elegant individuals' very own diversion personal entertainment services.
    Call us @9654120218
    Click here > > Call girls in Aerocity

  59. I am Ishika Singh from Delhi. Are you looking for some call girls or girlfriends with whom you can have sex and romance? So you can meet me through Paharganj escorts, assure you that you will feel very comfortable to meet me, I will love you so much, you will never forget me.

  60. Very informative post! There is a lot of information here that can help any business get started =
    frock for girls

  61. Thank you for this great article & it's very helpful, thanks for sharing. MME is the Top Manpower Recruitment Company in India providing complete HR solutions to prestigious companies. Our services for the professional Executive and top management staff, Payroll outsourcing services, Staffing services, International recruitment consultants, and other HR management solutions from last 26 years in organized sectors in India and as well as Globally. An Indian, Delhi based company dealing with 1000+, fortune clientele across the globe. MME started out a very humble beginning in the year 1994 and seen as a world leader in the HR industry with a short span of time.

  62. Promote Abhi is the top-rated SEO services company in Hyderabad or SEO consultant Hyderabad. As a top digital marketing agency, We offer the best SEO services in Hyderabad
    Now, you can buy indoor plants online near dwarka, new delhi with Ferns N Petals. Choose from our wide range of indoor plants on our website and send them across on various!
    Fix SilverSingles Login Problem ... decreases the genuineness of a user profile so it's terribly necessary to spot and solve the issue.
    For example, an Interior Designers and Decorators in Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh: may recommend changing the layout of the furniture. In other words, decorators are hands-off in the design process!
    chasecard asks you to verifycard delivery whenever you get a new credit card in the mail. This is the same thing as activating a Chase credit card.

  63. Grab the extraordinary Oracle Course with PLSQL from Infycle Technologies, the best software training institute in Chennai. Infycle offers the Best Oracle PLSQL Training in Chennai, with various IT demanding courses such as Big Data, Python, DevOps, Selenium, Full-Stack development, etc., in complete hands-on practical training with professional tutors in the field. In addition to that, the mock interviews will be done for the candidates so that they can face the interviews with total confidence. To have all these within your hands, call 7502633633 for having a free demo.

  64. Usually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job Man,Keep it up. Meanwhile visit our website for NMIMS assignment questions

  65. If You Want To Get The Best Articles About Several Disordr's Symptoms Like Insomnia, Anti-Anxiety, Pain Relief, ADHD, Muscle Relaxant, Insomnia, and Erectile Dysfunction Through Our Website.

    Muscle Relaxants Articles - Health And Doc
    Obesity Articles - Health And Doc
    Pain Relief Articles - Health And Doc
    Different Disorders Articles
    Visit Our Website

  66. Thanks in favor of sharing such a nice thinking, article is pleasant, thats why i have read it entirely.

    olx india customer number
    quikr contact
    suzuki bike contact number
    toshiba customer service
    ajio head office

  67. quite fine broadcast. I simply stumbled upon your blog and desired to pronounce that i've in reality loved surfing your blog posts. After each ill be subscribing for your feed and i reason you write behind extra quickly! Crack Hotspot Shield

  68. it is really a skillfully-researched content and super wording. I were given therefore engaged on this fabric that I couldnt wait studying. i'm impressed whilst your function and dogfight out-stroke. thanks. Wifi Hacker.Rar

  69. yes, i am thoroughly no examine deliberating this text, and that i simply tormented feeling proclaim that this text is completely useful and enlightening. I in conjunction with have a few gloomy piece of involved information !!!!!!thanks. Best Eid Wishes

  70. There will be best course in Hyderabad, duck creek policy program,duck creek can earn a salary 130000 per is useful to students career in the field you have interest visit my website link.thanks you

  71. ADF training institute are very limited and we are one of the best Azure data factory training institute in Hyderabad more details visit my website link


Commenting policy:

All comments are welcome here. I refuse to censor points of view that differ from my own.

I recognize that I may be challenging the deep-seated beliefs of some people, and perhaps stirring up emotions in others. However, I would ask:

- if you care to respond to anything that I have said, please do not simply link to or quote some statistic. Do not simply regurgitate things you have been told are true. Think about what I am saying. Respond with an argument. Offer something from your personal observations, and explain to me how you feel your statistic is connected to your experience.

- If you wish to be part of a discussion, try not to dismiss what I or a another commenter says out of hand. Yes, that means that some lines of thought or ideologies may not stand up to scrutiny (perhaps even my own).

- Remember, ad hominem attacks diminish everyone involved. If you want to criticize anything, do so passionately and directly - but debate is about attacking ideas, not people.

Have at you!